Skip to content
MT5MT4soonTradingViewsooncTradersoonNinjaTradersoonPythonsoon
Forex basics

Market maker

Also called Dealing desk broker, DD broker, Market making, Dealer

A market maker is a dealer that quotes two prices at once: a bid, where you can sell to it, and an ask, where you can buy from it. It takes the other side of your trade and aims to profit from the gap between the two.

If your broker is the market maker, the firm on the other side of your trade also sets the price you trade at. That puts real money at risk: a 2-pip widening of its spread can trigger your stop even if the market never reaches it.

How a market maker earns from both sides of the quote

The gap between the bid and the ask is the spread. Say one trader sells to the maker at the bid and another buys from it at the ask. The maker keeps the spread and ends up holding no position.

The illustrative order book below shows the market maker with the largest size at the best price on each side. A market order fills right away at the best price available, so it trades against those two quotes. The maker earns the shaded gap when one trader sells to it and another buys from it.

Order book with a market maker quoting both the best bid and the best ask
Illustrative exchange-style book: the maker earns the gap when one trader sells to it and another buys from it. A retail market-maker broker usually shows just its own two quotes.

Buyers and sellers rarely arrive in equal numbers. When most traders are buying, the maker ends up short, because it sold to every one of them. So it raises both its bid and its ask. That makes buying dearer and selling more attractive, so it can unload the short position it has built up. A buy you place into that rush fills higher.

Market maker raising both its bid and ask after a rush of buy orders
When buyers dominate, the maker is left short and moves the whole quote up, so a buy placed into the rush pays a higher ask (illustrative values).

Moving its quotes is one way to cut that risk. The other is to hedge, which means opening an offsetting trade with another dealer. If the maker hedges your trade, it earns only the spread. If not, it is betting against you: your loss is the broker's gain and your profit is its cost.

Market maker that hedges your trade vs one that keeps it
Maker hedges your trade
  • –Opens an offsetting trade with another dealer
  • –Earns only the spread
  • –Your result does not change its profit
Maker does not hedge
  • –Keeps the other side of your trade
  • –Is betting against you
  • –Your loss is the broker's gain
  • –Your profit is the broker's cost

Who plays this role depends on the market. In stock trading, wholesale firms that fill retail brokers' orders act as market makers. In retail forex and CFDs, the broker's own dealing desk often does the job.

Other forex brokers use STP (straight-through processing). They pass your order on to outside banks and dealers, called liquidity providers. An ECN (electronic communication network) matches your order inside a shared pool of prices from many participants.

Broker modelWho takes the other sideHow the broker is paidWhat to watch on fills
Market maker (dealing desk)The broker itselfSpread, plus your net losses on trades it does not hedgeRequotes (it rejects your price and offers a new one), spreads widening in news
STPOutside liquidity providersMarkup added to the spreadSlippage (a fill worse than the price you clicked) in fast markets
ECNOther participants in the shared poolCommission per lot on top of the raw spreadSlippage, partial fills (only part of your size fills at your price)

What the maker's quote costs you on one trade

The figures here are an illustrative example. The mid-price, halfway between the bid and the ask, is 1.1000 on EURUSD. Your market-maker broker quotes bid 1.0998 / ask 1.1002. You buy 1 standard lot (100,000 units) at the ask. Later the mid-price is 1.1010 and the quote is 1.1008 / 1.1012. You close at the bid.

Profit on 1 standard lot of EURUSD bought from a market maker
Mid-price move(1.1010 − 1.1000) ÷ 0.0001= 10 pips
Pip value for 1 standard lot100,000 × 0.0001= $10
Mid-price move in money10 × $10= $100
Spread paid to the maker(1.1002 − 1.0998) ÷ 0.0001 × $10= $40
Your profit$100 − $40= $60
Net result$60 profit

The mid-price moved 10 pips, worth $100 on 1 lot, but you kept $60. You gave up 2 pips on entry, because the ask sat above the mid. You gave up 2 more on exit, because the bid sat below it. For any trade, subtract the spread in pips from the move in pips, then multiply by your pip value.

A common misread involves stops around news. A long position's stop is a sell order, so it fills at the bid. If the maker widens the spread, the bid drops even when the mid-price barely moves. If the bid touched your stop while the mid-price stayed above it, the spread triggered your stop, not the market.

Spread widening around news pushes the bid onto a long position's stop while the mid-price stays at 1.1000Illustration
Spread widened by 2 pipsAsk in news1.1003Normal ask1.1002Mid-price (unchanged)1.1000Normal bid1.0998Bid in news = sell stop hit1.0997

How to tell whether your broker is the market maker

  • Order execution policy or client agreement. Look for "we act as principal", which means the broker trades on its own account. "We are the counterparty to your trades" means the same.
  • Account type. Fixed spreads with no commission often point to a dealing-desk account. A commission per lot on top of raw spreads usually means your orders go to outside liquidity providers.
  • What happens when you click. If orders often come back with a "price changed" message and a new price, the broker is probably checking your price against its own quote before it accepts the trade.
  • Depth of market. This is the list of orders waiting at each price. If it shows one price per side with nothing queued behind it, you may be seeing only the broker's own quote. It is a hint, not proof.
  • Conflict-of-interest policy. Regulated brokers usually publish one. Read how the firm says it handles trading against its clients.

Checks before you trade against a market maker quote

  • Note the spread during your usual trading hours. If it is more than twice that before a news release, wait or trade a smaller size.
  • Add the spread you expect at that time of day to your stop distance.
  • Log requotes and rejected orders. If they cluster around winning entries, raise it with the broker or move your account.
  • After a gap or a fast move, ask the broker for the tick history and compare your fill with its quotes at that moment. With any broker model, a plain stop fills at the next available price after a gap. A fill worse than the broker's own first quote after the gap is the red flag.

FAQ

Is a market maker broker bad for retail traders?

Not by itself. Test it: run a demo with it and one with an STP or ECN broker over the same week. Compare their spreads at news times and your requote logs on both, then judge by those results, not by the model alone.

Can a retail trader act like a market maker?

Partly. On an exchange, a limit order that waits in the book adds liquidity, just as a maker's quote does. Some venues charge a lower "maker" fee on those orders than the "taker" fee on market orders.

Related terms