Skip to content
MT5MT4soonTradingViewsooncTradersoonNinjaTradersoonPythonsoon

Holding Losing Trades Too Long: How It Fails Prop Challenges

Rule data from each firm’s official site, last checked 2026-11-15.

Holding losing trades while closing winners quickly is one of the most common reasons a prop firm challenge fails. A loser that was meant to cost 0.5% is given "a bit more room", then more, until one trade eats most of the daily loss limit. The fix is mechanical: place the stop with the order, and never move it further away.

The habit is hard to see from inside a trade, because each decision to wait feels reasonable at the time. It is easy to see in your history once you measure it.

Why a widened stop does more damage than a bad trade

Every challenge plan rests on one number: how much a single trade can lose. Your position size, your daily limit and your profit target are all built on it. When you widen a stop, you change that number after the trade is open, without changing the size.

That breaks the plan in two ways:

  • The loss grows past what you sized for. A trade sized to lose 500 at the stop can lose 1,000 or 2,000 once the stop moves.
  • The loss counts while it is open. At the firms in our database, floating (open) loss counts toward the daily loss limit. A losing trade you are "waiting on" is already using up your limit.

A bad trade with a stop is a cost of doing business. A bad trade without a firm stop is the kind that ends challenges.

Worked example: one widened stop on a 100,000 account

Here is an example with round numbers. You trade a 100,000 challenge with a 5% daily limit (5,000). Your plan risks 0.5% per trade, which is 500.

  1. You open 2 lots on EURUSD with a 25-pip stop. At about $10 per pip per lot, that is 2 × 10 × 25 = 500 at risk. On plan.
  2. The market moves 20 pips against you. You move the stop to 50 pips "to avoid getting stopped out by noise". Risk is now 2 × 10 × 50 = 1,000.
  3. It keeps going. You remove the stop and decide to wait. At 100 pips against, the open loss is 2 × 10 × 100 = 2,000, four times the plan.
  4. Earlier that day you lost 2 planned trades, 1,000 in total. With this trade open, the day is at 3,000. Two more planned losses, or 100 more pips on this one, and the 5,000 limit is gone.

The chart compares the three versions of the same trade. The setup did not change. Only the stop did.

Loss on the same 2-lot trade depending on where the stop ends upIllustration
Stop at 25 pips (as placed)
500 (0.5%)
Stop widened to 50 pips
1,000 (1%)
No stop, 100 pips against
2,000 (2%)

How to measure the habit in your own history

You do not need to remember which trades you moved. The duration of your trades shows it.

  1. Export your last 50 to 100 closed trades with open and close times.
  2. Split them into winners and losers.
  3. Find the median holding time of each group: sort the durations and take the middle one.
  4. Divide the losers' median by the winners' median.

If your typical loser stays open at least twice as much time as your typical winner, you are holding losers and cutting winners. For example, winners closed after a median of 40 minutes and losers after 2 hours gives a ratio of 3. Then check the biggest losers: compare each one's final loss with the risk it was sized for. Any loss well beyond 1R (the planned risk) means the stop moved or never existed.

Rules for stops that stay where you put them

The rule that does most of the work is the first one: the stop goes in with the order, at the same moment, not "once the trade settles".

Stop placed with the order vs stop managed by feel
Placed with the order
  • –Size is set from the stop distance
  • –Loss is known before the trade opens
  • –Stop can only move toward breakeven
  • –Open loss can never pass 1R
Added later or widened
  • –Size was set for a smaller stop
  • –Loss is decided under pressure
  • –Stop moves away as the market moves
  • –One trade can use most of the daily limit

A few rules that make this stick:

  • Size from the stop, not the other way round. Decide the stop distance first, then pick the lot size so that distance equals your risk per trade. If the stop feels too tight, the size is too big. See risk per trade.
  • One direction only. A stop may move closer to breakeven or into profit. It may never move further from the open price.
  • Add a time stop. If your winners usually work within a set time, a trade that has done nothing after twice that time is not working. Close it at market and take the smaller loss.
  • No adding to a loser. Adding size to a losing trade is a widened stop in disguise, and stacks open loss the same way a grid does. See floating loss from stacking.

Fix checklist for holding losers

  • Stop placed in the same order ticket as the trade. No exceptions.
  • Lot size calculated from the stop distance and your risk per trade.
  • Stops move only toward breakeven or profit, never away.
  • Time stop: close any trade still open after 2 times your winners' median holding time.
  • Never add to a losing position.
  • Weekly check: losers' median holding time divided by winners' median. Target: below 2.
  • Any trade that lost more than 1.2R gets a written note: what moved, and why.

Firms set the loss limits, not your stops, and their terms on how open loss is measured differ and can change. Your stop rule is what keeps one trade from reaching those limits.

Questions

What if the market often hits my stop and then reverses?

That usually means the stop sits at an obvious level or is too tight for normal movement on that symbol and timeframe. The answer is a wider stop chosen before the trade, with a smaller size so the money at risk stays the same. Widening it mid-trade at the same size is what turns a 500 risk into a 2,000 loss.

Is a mental stop good enough?

Not in a challenge. A mental stop depends on you acting at the worst moment, and it gives no protection if the connection drops or the market jumps. A stop placed on the order sits on the server and fills even when you are not watching.

Should I also cut winners later to balance the ratio?

The ratio is a symptom, so treat the cause first. Fixing losers usually brings the ratio down on its own. If winners still close much faster than your plan says, write an exit rule for them too, such as a fixed target in R or a trailing stop, and follow it the same way.

Simulation only. Results use each firm’s published rules as read on the date shown. Firms can change rules at any time, apply terms they do not publish, and make the final decision on every account, so passing here does not mean you will pass the real challenge. This is not financial advice; read the firm’s current terms before you pay.