Skip to content
MT5MT4soonTradingViewsooncTradersoonNinjaTradersoonPythonsoon

What Does a Short Position Mean? How Selling First Works

beginner8 min readNov 16, 20260 views
Learn Forex from zero · lesson 53 of 130 · chapter 1

A short position means you sell first and plan to buy back later, betting that the price will fall. If the price drops below your selling price, the gap is your profit. If it rises, the gap is your loss. In forex, shorting EUR/USD means selling euros for dollars. With stocks, you borrow shares, sell them, and return them later.

This matters because a short is not just a long trade turned upside down. Its loss has no fixed ceiling. Also, on some accounts, a sell click closes a trade you already hold instead of opening a new short.

How a short position makes or loses money

A normal purchase is a long position: you buy, wait, and want the price to rise. A short reverses the order. You sell at today's price, and you finish the trade by buying the same amount back.

Your result is the selling price minus the buy-back price, multiplied by your position size. When the price falls, that number is positive. When the price rises, it turns negative. Commissions, spreads and other broker charges come off the result either way.

Traders call the two directions going long and short. Long means you profit from rises. Short means you profit from falls. Most of the trade is the same: the chart and the order window don't change, you just press the opposite button.

Going short in forex: selling one currency to buy another

Every forex quote is a pair. The first currency is the base currency and the second is the quote currency. When you short EUR/USD, you sell euros and buy dollars at the same moment. You are betting that the euro weakens against the dollar.

Every quote already has a buy side and a sell side, so you don't borrow anything to go short in forex. You simply press Sell. To close, you buy back the same number of units. You can also close part of it: for example, buy back half and leave the rest open.

The price you get matters. A short opens at the bid price, the lower of the two quotes. It closes at the ask price, the higher one. The gap between them is the bid-ask spread, so a new short starts slightly in the red. The ladder below shows an example quote.

Where a EUR/USD short opens and closes on an example quoteIllustration
Spread: 2 pipsAsk: your short closes here1.20020Bid: your short opens here1.20000

In this example the spread is 2 pips. Say you sold 10,000 euros at 1.20000 and closed straight away at 1.20020. You would lose 0.00020 × 10,000 = $2 before the price had moved at all.

Worked example: shorting EUR/USD from 1.2000 to 1.1900

The figures in this section are an illustrative example. Suppose EUR/USD trades at 1.2000 and you expect the euro to weaken. You sell 10,000 units (10,000 euros) at 1.2000 and set a stop loss at 1.2050. Later the pair trades at 1.1900, and you buy the 10,000 units back. To keep the numbers simple, the spread is left out.

The chart below shows the trade. The price climbs to your entry, then slides down to your buy-back level while your stop sits above.

EUR/USD short sold at 1.2000 and bought back at 1.1900Illustration
Stop loss 1.20501.2050Sell 1.20001.2000Buy back 1.19001.1900SellBuy back

Now the arithmetic. One pip on EUR/USD is 0.0001. With 10,000 units, each pip is worth 10,000 × 0.0001 = $1.

Profit and risk on the example EUR/USD short
Price drop1.2000 - 1.1900= 0.0100
Pips gained0.0100 ÷ 0.0001= 100
Value of one pip10,000 × 0.0001= $1
Profit100 × $1= $100
Planned loss if the stop fills at 1.2050(1.2050 - 1.2000) × 10,000= $50
Loss if price gaps past the stop to 1.2100(1.2100 - 1.2000) × 10,000= $100
Result when bought back at 1.1900+$100

If the pair had risen to 1.2050 instead, your stop would have bought the units back there. That is a 50-pip loss, or $50. Spread and any fees come on top of both results.

Here is the formula to copy for any short: profit or loss = (sell price − buy-back price) × units. A positive answer is a profit. A negative answer is a loss.

Why a short's loss has no ceiling

A long position has a floor: the price cannot fall below zero, so the most you can lose is what you paid. A short has no such floor working for you. The price can keep rising, so in theory the loss has no limit.

A stock example makes this concrete. Short 100 shares at $60, and the price rises to $80. Your loss is ($80 − $60) × 100 = $2,000. The chart below compares that short with a long bought at the same $60.

Profit and loss of a 100-share short versus a long, both opened at $60
The long's worst case is fixed. The short's line keeps falling as the price climbs.

Two events can turn that open-ended risk into real losses:

  • Margin call. If the price rises sharply against your short, your broker may ask you to deposit more money or close the position at a loss. With leveraged trades, losses can be larger than the money you deposited.
  • Short squeeze. A heavily shorted asset jumps suddenly. Short sellers rush to buy back, and their buying pushes the price higher still, which forces even more of them to buy.

A stop loss does not remove the unlimited-loss risk completely. A stop is an order to buy back, not a guaranteed price. If the price jumps past your stop, for example over a weekend, around news or in a short squeeze, the order fills at the next available price. Take the worked example above as an illustration: you are short 10,000 units from 1.2000 with a stop at 1.2050. If EUR/USD opens on Monday at 1.2100, the stop fills near 1.2100. Your loss is (1.2100 − 1.2000) × 10,000 = $100, not the $50 you planned.

Long and short positions in stocks, futures, forwards and options

The same idea appears across markets. Here is how each market handles it:

MarketHow you go shortHow you go longDo you borrow to go short?Extra point to watch
ForexSell the base currency against the quote currencyBuy the base currencyNoSpread and overnight financing
Stocks (a short equity position)Borrow shares, sell them, buy them back laterBuy sharesYesBorrowing costs, which can be high for hard-to-borrow stocks; shorting can be restricted, or banned during crises
Futures and forwardsAgree to sell at a fixed price on a future dateAgree to buy at a fixed price on a future dateNoThe contract has an end date
OptionsSell (write) an option contractBuy an option contractNoThe writer takes on the contract's obligation

Forwards follow the same row of the table as futures: the side that has agreed to sell at a fixed price holds the short position, and it gains if the market price ends below that agreed price.

A net long position describes your overall exposure when you hold trades in both directions. Add up what you bought and subtract what you sold. For example, if you hold 30,000 units of EUR/USD long and 10,000 units short, you are net long 20,000 units. Overall, your account gains when the euro rises. Net short is the reverse.

Net long position: 30,000 units of EUR/USD long minus 10,000 units shortIllustration
Long EUR/USD
30,000 units
Short EUR/USD
10,000 units
Net position
Net long 20,000 units

Mistakes that cost beginners money when going short

Not deciding your buy-back price before you sell

A short with no planned exit, or one sized as if the risk were capped, can lose far more than you expected. Your stop is your planned limit, not a guaranteed one. Fix: before you sell, write down the price at which you will buy back if you are wrong, and set it as your stop loss. If you cannot name that price, do not open the short. Then size from the stop distance. In the worked example, a 50-pip stop × $1 per pip = $50 planned risk. If that is more than you can afford, trade fewer units.

Pressing Sell while you already hold a long

Selling EUR/USD does not always open a short. If you already hold a long, a sell order may simply close or reduce it. On other account types, it opens a separate short next to the long. Fix: check your open positions before you click, and know which way your account handles opposite orders.

Forgetting that your short closes at the ask

Many charts plot only the bid. Your short's stop and target are hit when the ask reaches them, so a stop can trigger even if the bid line on your chart never touched it. Fix: leave room for the spread when you place stops and targets, and expect it to widen around news.

A short's stop loss is hit by the ask price while the bid line on the chart stays below it
Illustrative values: the chart plots the bid, but your short closes at the ask, so the stop triggers when the ask touches it even though the bid stays below.

Adding to a short that is moving against you

"It has to come down" is how beginners get caught in a squeeze. Every addition raises your risk just as the market proves you wrong. Fix: never add to a losing short. Add only when the trade is in profit and your stop has moved.

Shorting a stock without checking the costs and rules

Borrowed shares cost money for as long as you hold them. Shorting can also be limited when markets are under stress. Fix: check the borrowing cost and any restrictions before you open a short equity position.

Checklist before you open any short:

  • I know whether this order opens a new short or closes an existing long.
  • My stop is set with room for the spread, and I can afford (sell price − stop price) × units.
  • I know my costs: spread, commission, and borrowing or overnight fees.
  • I will not add to this trade if it moves against me.

FAQ

Do I pay anything to keep a forex short open overnight?

Often, yes. Leveraged forex positions held past the daily rollover usually get a small financing charge or credit, called swap. The amount depends on the interest rates of the two currencies, and a short and a long on the same pair usually get different amounts. Your platform shows the swap rate for each pair, so check it before you hold a short for days.

Can I practise short selling without risking real money?

Yes. A practice account with virtual money lets you open and close shorts, watch the spread, and see how stops trigger at the ask. Use it until you can predict the result of a short before you close it.

Can I hold a long and a short on the same pair at once?

On some account types, yes. The two trades stay open side by side. Your real exposure is the net of the two, and you pay the spread on both. If they are the same size, you are just paying costs while your exposure is close to zero.

Part of Forex basics: more guides, terms and free tools on this subject.