Skip to content
MT5MT4soonTradingViewsooncTradersoonNinjaTradersoonPythonsoon

Is 1:2 Risk Reward Good? It Depends on One Number: Your Win Rate

A 1:2 risk reward is good when your win rate at that target stays clearly above 33.3%, the break-even rate before costs, and above about 35–38% once spread and commission are added on typical stops. Below that, 1:2 loses money however good it looks. The ratio is only half the test; the other half is how often price actually reaches a target twice as far away as your stop.

1:2 is popular because it is forgiving: you can lose two trades for every win and still be flat. That only helps if the target is realistic for the instrument and the timeframe you trade.

The test: compare your win rate with 1:2 break-even

Use this if/then rule on a backtest or a trade log of at least 100 trades:

  • If your win rate at 2R is at least 5 points above the after-cost break-even for your stop size (about 41% on a 20-pip stop, 43% on a 10-pip stop), 1:2 has a working edge.
  • If it is above break-even after costs but by less than 5 points, the edge is thin. On 100 trades, the margin of error alone is about ±5 points. Cut costs or improve the setup before adding size.
  • If it is below break-even after costs, 1:2 does not work for that setup. Test a closer target, or a different stop placement, on the same trades.

The after-cost line depends on the stop size. With a 1.5-pip round-trip cost, a 1:2 trade with a 10-pip stop breaks even at 38.3%, while one with a 40-pip stop breaks even at 34.6%. The break-even win rate guide shows the formula and the margin of error on small samples.

Worked example: 100 trades at 1:2

Here is a worked example. A trader logs 100 trades, each with a 20-pip stop and a 40-pip target, and a 1.5-pip cost per trade. 40 trades reach the target and 60 hit the stop.

  • Each win nets 40 − 1.5 = 38.5 pips, which is 38.5 ÷ 20 = 1.925R
  • Each loss costs 20 + 1.5 = 21.5 pips, which is 1.075R
  • Wins: 40 × 1.925 = +77R
  • Losses: 60 × 1.075 = −64.5R
  • Net: +12.5R over 100 trades, or +0.125R per trade

Before costs, the same trades would make 40 × 2 − 60 = +20R. Costs took more than a third of the edge. At a 35% win rate, the result after costs is 35 × 1.925 − 65 × 1.075 = 67.4 − 69.9 = −2.5R: a small loss, even though 35% is above the 33.3% line on paper.

Net result of 100 trades at 1:2 after a 1.5-pip cost (20-pip stop), by win rateIllustration
40% wins
+12.5R
45% wins
+27.5R
50% wins
+42.5R

Check: at 45%, 45 × 1.925 − 55 × 1.075 = 86.6 − 59.1 = +27.5R. At 50%, 96.25 − 53.75 = +42.5R. Each 5 points of win rate adds 15R per 100 trades, because every trade that flips from loss to win swings by about 3R. You can check any single trade's ratio and break-even line with the risk reward calculator.

1:2 compared with 1:1 and 1:3

Each ratio asks for a different kind of trading. Moving the target changes both the payout and how often you reach it.

1 : 11 : 21 : 3
Break-even win rate (before costs)50%33.3%25%
Losses one win pays for123
Target distance vs a 20-pip stop20 pips40 pips60 pips
Share of a 2-pip cost in the reward10%5%3.3%
Typical feelMany wins, small edge per tradeBalancedLong losing streaks between wins

None of the three is "best". The right one is the ratio where your hit rate leaves the widest gap above break-even. See the full grid in the risk reward vs win rate table.

When 1:2 is a poor fit

When the target is beyond the day's usual range. If a 1:2 target on an intraday trade needs more movement than the instrument usually makes in a whole day, the target is reached less often, and the win rate you tested on closer targets no longer applies. Compare the target distance with the average daily range before you settle on 2R.

When the stop is very tight. On a 5-pip stop, a 1-pip spread makes a 1:2 trade really (10 − 1) ÷ (5 + 1) = 1:1.5. Break-even moves from 33.3% to 40%.

When 2R crosses an obvious level. A target placed just beyond a recent high or low, a round number or a session extreme is reached less often than one placed just before it. Read the chart first, then the ratio.

How to test 1:2 on your own trades

  1. Take your last 100 or more trades from the same setup.
  2. For each, record the stop distance and the furthest the trade moved in your favour before the stop or the exit.
  3. Count how many reached 1R, 1.5R, 2R and 3R before hitting the stop.
  4. For each level, compute the result per trade after costs, using the trading expectancy formula.
  5. Keep the target with the highest expectancy, not the highest ratio.

This uses data you already have, and it answers the question for your setup rather than in general.

Questions

Is 1:2 good for prop firm challenges?

The ratio is only one part of the challenge. The daily and total loss limits are counted in money, so what matters is how many losses in a row you can take at your risk per trade. If your 1:2 targets are reached more often than 1:3 targets would be on the same entries, your losing streaks are shorter, which helps against a daily limit. The edge still depends on your win rate after costs.

Should the ratio be 1:2 on every trade?

A fixed ratio is easier to test and to measure. Varying it trade by trade, with targets set from the chart, can work too, but then you need to judge results on average win and average loss, not on a single ratio.

Use the free risk reward calculatorRun your own numbers in a few seconds, with the full guide on the same page.